Because of the oath I took when first starting out as an anime fan, I am obliged to continue watching the second series of Bakuman ‘til the bitter end. However, I shall not be watching the third series; I would like to take this opportunity, as the second series begins to draw to a close, to justify my decision.
Bakuman revolves around two teenage boys, Mashiro and Takagi who decide to work together to create manga and fulfil Mashiro’s dream of marrying Miho, the girl he loves, once one of their works get an anime adaptation. Now, quite possibly the best thing about Bakuman is its story- I think it was very clever of mangakas Obata and Ohba to choose a story such as this that is bound to fascinate all anime viewers alike. Indeed, the show shines brightest when focusing on the creation of manga and the manga industry itself. The more ‘romantic’ aspects of the show, however, are much less satisfactory, which brings me to my first gripe.
OK, perhaps it is a tad strange for me to complain about how unrealistic any aspect of any particular anime is given that it’s, you know, anime! In anime, it’s possible to have hair any colour of the rainbow, and things such as gravity and underwear seem not to exist. Yet, I just can’t get over how unrealistic and idealistic the relationship between Mashiro and Azuki is. I do not believe in love at first sight, nor do I believe a lifelong commitment such as marriage should be entered into before you’ve even had a proper conversation with the person in question, let alone hold hands with them, go on a date with them or do any of those things couples usually do! The fact that the pair hardly know anything about each other, Mashiro is hardly ever there for Azuki and he openly prioritises his career over her, make their ‘love’ seem even more shallow. I’ve read about more modern, sincere approaches to love in Victorian literature! Considering Mashiro’s ‘love’ for Miho is presented as being his biggest drive, it really bothers me that it’s so weak and artificial.
However, it is not just the idealistic nature of the show that bothers me but, you got it, its rampant sexism. Within the first handful of episodes alone Mashiro’s mother’s wishes for her son are overruled by Mashiro’s father who insists she simply doesn’t understand men’s dreams. Stupid woman, how dare you show concern for you son, whose uncle, a mangaka himself, worked himself to death! Why shouldn’t you wish for your son to jeopardise his education to enter into an extremely competitive industry where success is never guaranteed and all your hard work can be undone by a single word, “cancelled”? Takagi also suggests smart girls are unattractive, a point reinforced by the fact that, one of the few girls in the show, a driven, intelligent girl, is made to seem wholly unlikeable. Let’s face it, Iwase’s a giant bitch!
This sexism isn’t simply confined to the first series however, during the second series Azuki is criticised for bothering her boyfriend with her problems when he obviously has more important things to worry about, Mashiro’s reason for not wanting Miho to pose in a swimsuit for a photo-book was something along the lines of not wanting others to see her like that, objectifying her and Hiramaru’s dream is having “a pretty woman” to look after him. I could go on. Some may argue this is merely my interpretation of the events of the show but, to that I would say, it is highly coincidental that my own, personal, ‘incorrect’ interpretation is one that is shared by hundreds, if not thousands of people who have watched the show! Why should I, or anyone else have to accept this sexism simply because the show is from the perspective of two boys?
I could go into the more aesthetic aspects of the show, e.g. its ‘derpy’ animation and the ridiculous faces some of the male characters pull, which seems unsuited to Obata’s art but, I feel as though I would just be nit-picking, especially as these aren’t the aspects I most value in a show.
In any case, I have had just about as much as I can take of Bakuman’s sexism and idealisation of relationships, (I’m surprised I started the second series, to be honest) I shall certainly endeavour to devote my time to more worthy shows in future.
PREACH
This damn show frustrated me completely. Miho and Mashiro are idiots. The writers spoiled the plot by adding relationship between them. Too orthodox in nature as if the protagonist needs to be in love. If I was Mashiro, I would had dumped her. At last but not the least, fuck the sexiest show. Eiji should get a spin off. It will be far better.
“Considering Mashiro’s ‘love’ for Miho is presented as being his biggest drive, it really bothers me that it’s so weak and artificial.” You made a name mistake in there. Thought I’d let you know!
I like Bakuman. I don’t watch it for the relationship in it, I watch it for entertainment. That’s all I can really say!
I think you’ll find I haven’t made an error, I simply referred to Azuki by her first name, Miho.
There are only two things I find entertaining about the show and that’s Hiramaru and Eiji, and they don’t get nearly enough screen-time for my liking!
Well don’t I feel like an idiot… I was thinking Miho was Takagi’s girlfriend.
I agree, the romance and drama really bothers me till death. And don’t even mention Nakai or I’ll go crazy.
Great that the manga-part is good, bad that it’s relying on shitty drama. Hate it hate it hate it.
II know you warned me not to but, I’m gonna anyway! >: D
I actually liked, and felt sorry for, Nakai during series one- it was interesting to meet a character that lacked drive as a result of his previous failures, a nice contrast to all of the other Bakuman mangakas. But no, this series turned him into nothing more than a dirty lech…
I got bored half way through
I prefer the manga
Oh hey, haven’t seen you on my blog before! Welcome!
Yes, I’ve heard the manga is far better, especially in terms of art which, by the looks of it, is stunning…
The manga part of Bakuman isn’t good- the first season did the same thing over and over with it:
Work really hard,
Get excited,
Get knocked down,
Sulk,
Then work hard again…
It was so boring and their manga sucks! I hate Bakuman, it deserves to burn! Eiji for the win though!
Really? I found it very exciting. It has grown a bit stale in this season though. This is why I feel annoyed over the fact that the character interractions are so… shallow and dumb.
Editing post
In reply to marow
I’ve seen complaints like these before, and the issues with women got to me quite a bit too. It’s a big part of why I had so much trouble reading it, since there are so many boneheaded aspects to it that it’s hard to work up the nerve to keep going.
You couldn’t have described how mediocre this show really is in a better way. I’m a big fan of Tsugumi and Takeshi for coming up with Death Note, but Bakuman in my opinion is not only a failure but it’s also a major ”Let Down” for the numerous amount of fans that they gained with Death Note.
But the good news is that they finally finished Bakuman and hopefully they’ll make something a lot more intriguing.
I’m glad that what I said resonated with you!
The huge success of Death Note makes me wonder why Ohba and Obata didn’t just create another manga similar in genre to it. Perhaps they just wanted to try something new, develop their skills in other areas, but why abandon what is clearly a winning formula for them? I don’t know…
Pingback: A year of Watashi wa bucho!! « Watashi wa bucho!!
lol…the female characters are pathetic.. .Its sad when your favorite artists come up with stuff like this .Totally agreed with the conclusion
Bakuman is the best!
Well, I suppose that being a fan of Bakuman, it’s kinda useless to comment on it, because it will sound like a “defense attorney”… But as someone who hates sexism myself, I understand why you got sick of Bakuman.
HOWEVER… Bakuman is stated as a “lifestyle mangá”, which means it’s a mangá about the life and routine of the characters. In this case, two mangaka-aspiring characters. And if they live in Japan, than we are certainly going to read something about the Japanese culture and its society, therefore, its way of thinking. And, unfortunately, Japanese society has a problem regarding to sexism. So, Bakuman had 2 options, write a story about boys who want to be mangaká, or write a story that would change the paradigm of sexism in Japan, fight the man-made society they have there.
And as bakuman itself states, they’re writing a shonen mangá, shonen has “rules”.
Well, what I’m trying to say is that, Japan has a different culture, a different way of seeing things. For us, westerns, sexism is something worth fighting against, women were able to break the chains of masculinity and fight for their right. But in Japan, that is not so true. Women are still bound to their chains of their culture.
But as a western, you don’t have to keep following the story. Of course!
About their love… As the same time Mashiro puts is job in first place, Azuki does the same… Well…
I mean… It’s kinda unrealistic, and the characters say that themselves (like Kaya and Takagi many times have said). But we have our conception of love. They have theirs.
What I mean is… Try to check a bit of HOW Japanese people think, how is their “society thinking” and maybe Bakuman will make more sense. It’s still going to be sexist… but It might make more sense,
http://www.mangatherapy.com/post/1543578362/sexism-in-japan-bakuman
This website pretty much states what I tried to say =)
Actually, while I agree with everything you’ve said, you really should check Bakuman 3 out. It has A LOT less love elements, A LOT less sexism, and much more focus on manga. The story also becomes pretty addictive.
Not to mention the awesome villains this season has! And the terrifying plot line in the middle of the season! Also, I’m noticing a lot of pissed off Death Note fans who can’t accept how mangaka can do two completely different works just like we can (American Horror Story and Glee, Beavis and Butthead and King of the Hill, hello!?